What If...? (2021)

Overview

One of the boldest gateways from the Marvel Cinematic Universe into the world of animation, What If...? is an anthology series streaming on Disney+ that completely flips the familiar stories Marvel Studios has built over the years. Launched in 2021, the production faithfully adapts both the name and the concept from its comic book source, offering viewers an answer to the question "what if events had unfolded differently?" in a new universe every episode. Shaped with contributions from experienced names like producer David Michie, the series consciously departs from the MCU's usual format both visually and narratively.

The series' most striking feature is that most of the characters we know from the live-action films are voiced again by their original voice actors. This detail eliminates the potential disconnect that a shift to animation might create, and makes it easier for viewers to form an emotional bond with these alternate universes. The story structure, narrated by a cosmic entity called the Watcher, makes it possible to experience each episode as an independent short film in its own right.

Plot

Centering on the multiverse concept of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, What If...? explores how a small but critical variable in the storylines we know can lead to major consequences. Scenarios such as a familiar hero making a different decision, an unexpected character gaining superpowers, or an event being experienced by a different person are each explored through a distinct "what if" question in every episode.

The Watcher, the mystical entity observing these alternate timelines, guides the viewer, tracing the traces of the films we've watched before while also creating entirely original character combinations and conflicts. Although the series proceeds through standalone episodes, it evolves toward a bigger narrative as connections are drawn between these universes toward the end of each season. This structure is designed to appeal both to viewers seeking single-episode satisfaction and to those who want to follow the bigger picture.

Why Watch It?

For viewers familiar with the Marvel universe, What If...? offers the opportunity to look at well-known stories from a completely new perspective. The series' biggest appeal is that it breaks the usual hero-villain dynamics, allowing for unexpected character developments. A character who remained in the background in one film can rise to the lead role here, or a beloved hero can take an entirely different path.

The animation technique is also one of the series' strengths. The visual style is enriched with dynamic camera angles and cinematic compositions reminiscent of live-action scenes, which counters the perception of animation as generally a "lighter" genre. Additionally, each episode having its own distinct tone prevents the series from becoming monotonous; while one episode offers an action-packed adventure, the next can shift into a darker, tension-filled atmosphere.

The fact that most of the original voice cast returns strengthens familiarity with the characters and helps viewers find these alternate versions more believable. This elevates the series beyond being a mere "spin-off," making it an integral part of the MCU.

Who Is It Suitable For?

What If...? offers the highest satisfaction primarily to viewers who have followed the Marvel Cinematic Universe films and know the characters and storylines. The references and callbacks become much more meaningful for those who have watched the previous films. However, the series is kept accessible enough in its storytelling to be followed with only a basic familiarity.

It's also a fitting choice for science fiction fans curious about alternate universe and multiverse concepts, viewers who enjoy concise storytelling, and adult audiences looking for mature and complex narratives in animated form. Parental guidance is recommended for children due to the dark themes and action scenes in some episodes. Those who enjoy a mix of action, drama, and dark humor will find plenty of episodes that appeal to them in the series.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Offers a fresh perspective on familiar stories with original and bold "what if" scenarios.

2. The return of the vast majority of original voice actors gives continuity to the characters.

3. Each episode offers experiences in different genres and tones, increasing variety.

Cons:

1. Some episodes may create a lack of context for viewers unfamiliar with the source films.

2. The balance of quality and pacing between episodes can occasionally be inconsistent.

Genre and Tone

While the series is fundamentally based on science fiction and superhero genres, the freedom offered by the anthology format allows it to shift into a different subgenre with each episode. Some episodes give off a classic superhero film feel with intense action sequences, while others take on a darker, tension-filled atmosphere that even carries horror elements. Dark humor also comes into play from time to time, lightening the series' weight.

While the overall tone suggests it shouldn't be considered separate from the MCU's cinematic universe, the freedom provided by animation allows for a more experimental, boundary-pushing style of storytelling. The visual style, with its dark color palettes and dynamic scene compositions, moves away from the "cartoon" perception of animation to build a cinematic identity.

Runtime and Viewing Experience

Episodes are generally kept around thirty minutes, making the series a fast and intense viewing experience. Thanks to the anthology structure, viewers can watch episodes independently in whatever order they like, without having to finish the series in one sitting. However, as the season progresses, the connections that form make sequential viewing more satisfying.

Similar Productions

• Love, Death & Robots (2019) – A science fiction series blending different genres in an anthology format.

• Rick and Morty (2013) – An animated series that tackles the concept of the multiverse with a humorous tone.

• Invincible (2021) – A production that presents the superhero theme with a more mature and surprise-filled narrative.

• Star Trek: Lower Decks (2020) – An animated series that approaches a familiar universe from a different perspective.

• The Twilight Zone (1959) – A classic anthology series dealing with alternate scenarios and themes of the unknown.

Final Assessment

What If...? offers a bold and creative anthology experience that serves as a breath of fresh air for viewers who have consumed the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Stories in which familiar characters proceed down unexpected paths make it possible to both form a nostalgic connection and have a viewing experience full of surprises. Accessible thanks to its short episode lengths and standalone story structure, the series stands out as a production worth discovering for anyone curious about the MCU. It's a satisfying choice for those who want to enjoy the visual freedom offered by animation while navigating between episodes of varying tones.